Science Fair Projects Ideas - Movement paradox

All Science Fair Projects

      

Science Fair Project Encyclopedia for Schools!

  Search    Browse    Forum  Coach    Links    Editor    Help    Tell-a-Friend    Encyclopedia    Dictionary     

Science Fair Project Encyclopedia

For information on any area of science that interests you,
enter a keyword (eg. scientific method, molecule, cloud, carbohydrate etc.).
Or else, you can start by choosing any of the categories below.

Movement paradox

A movement paradox is a grammatical phenomenon which, particularly according to proponents of lexical functional grammar, presents some problems for a transformational approach to syntax. Take the following example sentences:

We talked about the fact that he was sick for days.
The fact that he was sick, we talked about for days.

These two sentences are related by movement in a transformational analysis: in the second sentence, the phrase "the fact that he was sick" has been moved to the front of the sentence for emphasis. However, there are pairs of sentences like this in which the sentence without movement is ungrammatical while the sentence with movement is not:

*We talked about that he was sick for days.
That he was sick, we talked about for days.

This may be difficult to explain in an analysis based on movement, since it is not obvious how the second sentence can be grammatical if it is derived from a movement operation applying to an ungrammatical structure, i.e. a structure like that of the first sentence. A more striking example of a movement paradox can be found in English morphology:

*I aren't allowed to do that
Aren't I allowed to do that?

In a transformational analysis, the question is formed by the movement of aren't to the front of the sentence, which does not explain why aren't is acceptable as a contraction of am not only after movement. The problem may be alleviated if one assumes that morphological processes apply after movement, but this raises a further problem:

*Am not I allowed to do that?

If morphological processes applied after movement then the sentence above would presumably be the one from which "Aren't I allowed to do that" would derive, but it is clearly ungrammatical.

Lexical functional grammar avoids these difficulties to some extent because it does not have a movement operation.


Reference

Bresnan, Joan. 2001. Lexical-Functional Syntax. Oxford: Blackwell.

Last updated: 08-09-2005 10:58:26
10-26-2009 08:16:03
The contents of this article is licensed from www.wikipedia.org under the GNU Free Documentation License. Click here to see the transparent copy and copyright details
Science kits, science lessons, science toys, maths toys, hobby kits, science games and books - these are some of many products that can help give your kid an edge in their science fair projects, and develop a tremendous interest in the study of science. When shopping for a science kit or other supplies, make sure that you carefully review the features and quality of the products. Compare prices by going to several online stores. Read product reviews online or refer to magazines.

Start by looking for your science kit review or science toy review. Compare prices but remember, Price $ is not everything. Quality does matter.
Science Fair Coach
What do science fair judges look out for?
ScienceHound
Science Fair Projects for students of all ages
All Science Fair Projects.com Site
All Science Fair Projects Homepage
Search | Browse | Links | From-our-Editor | Books | Help | Contact | Privacy | Disclaimer | Copyright Notice