What speeds up a slow computer more -- a faster processor or more memory? You swap the CPU (central processing unit) and RAM (random access memory) in a desktop computer and time how long each setup takes to start up and load a game.
Four hardware combinations are tested. You measure startup time, game load time, and game load time with five other programs running in the background.
The results reveal whether clock speed or memory size has a bigger effect on everyday performance.
Hypothesis
The hypothesis is that increasing the CPU speed will make a computer work faster.
A faster CPU carries out each task more quickly, but it does not work alone. By swapping the CPU and RAM in a desktop computer and timing startup and game loading, you can isolate how much the processor chip contributes compared to available memory. When you measure performance with five other programs running, the results reveal whether the chip executing every instruction or the memory feeding it data has a bigger effect on speed.
RAM is your computer's short-term memory, holding whatever it needs right now so it works fast. In this experiment, you test four hardware combinations and measure game load time with five other programs running in the background. That background-load test directly targets RAM because short-term memory must hold the game and all five extra programs at the same time.
The CPU and RAM are the physical parts that determine how fast a computer can start up and run programs. When you swap these components in a desktop computer and time four different hardware combinations, you can measure which one has a bigger effect on everyday performance — clock speed or memory size. Startup time, game load time, and game load time with five programs running in the background all reveal how these parts work together under real conditions.
A benchmark becomes especially useful when comparing hardware upgrades under realistic conditions. You time how long each CPU-and-RAM combination takes to start up the computer and load a game — first alone, then with five other programs running in the background. Running the same set test across all four hardware setups produces direct, comparable measurements of everyday performance.
Method & Materials
You will upgrade the computer's CPU and RAM, measure the time it takes to start up the computer and start a game, and observe the results.
You will need a desktop computer, a CPU, RAM, a computer game software, and a stopwatch.
MEL Math — hands-on math experiment kits delivered monthly — makes abstract concepts tangible. (Affiliate link)
The results show that using a CPU with a higher clock speed will enable the computer to operate faster, whilst adding the RAM does not make much difference unless there are other application programs running in the background.
Why do this project?
This science project is interesting because it shows how different components of a computer can affect its performance.
Also Consider
Consider repeating the experiment with different brands of CPU, or with different types of RAM with different frequency ratings.
Full project details
Additional information and source material for this project are available below.