
Water Purification: Three Methods Compared
Hard
Which water purification method removes the most contaminants? This project puts three methods head to head: filtration vs. distillation vs. solar pasteurization.
You test tap water and Chicago River water for eight contaminants:
- pH
- Chlorine
- Hardness
- Nitrate
- Phosphate
- Ammonia nitrogen
- Copper
- Iron
You run each water sample through all three purification methods. Then you retest and compare. You also introduce E. coli B bacteria into sterile water and test each method's ability to kill it.
Distillation removed the most contaminants and killed the most bacteria. Filtration was fastest and cheapest. Solar pasteurization ranked last in three of four categories.
Hypothesis
The hypothesis is that distillation is the most effective method of water purification.
Method & Materials
You will test tap and river water for various contaminants, then put the samples through the processes of solar pasteurization, distillation, and filtration. You will also take a test tube with E. coli B bacteria and inoculate it in 4 separate jars of sterile water.
You will need titrants, reagents, meters, a solar box cooker, an activated carbon filter, 20 petri plates prepared with EMB agar, and nutrient broth.
Results
The results showed that distillation was the most effective method of water purification, followed by filtration and then solar pasteurization. Distillation was the most efficient in terms of quality, speed, and cost, and was also the best at killing bacteria.
Why do this project?
This science project is interesting and unique because it tests the effectiveness of three different methods of water purification and compares the results.
Also Consider
Experiment variations to consider include testing different types of water, such as lake or ocean water, or testing different types of bacteria.
Full project details
Additional information and source material for this project are available below.Share this Science Project:
Related Science Fair Project Ideas
Collect tap water from five old houses with lead pipes and five new houses with PVC, then send all ten samples to a lab for lead testing.
Hard
Collect lake water at four depths and test for acidity, cloudiness, ammonia, and nitrates to map how pollution changes below the surface.
Hard
Push bacteria and viruses through packed soil columns to find out whether agricultural soil can protect groundwater from contamination.
Hard
Share this Science Project:
