
Antibacterial vs. Regular Soap on Bacteria
Hard
Does antibacterial soap kill more germs than regular soap? Many people assume the antibacterial label means better protection. Research from Columbia University found no difference in bacteria counts between the two types.
You grow three types of bacteria in a lab: E. coli, Staphylococcus aureus, and Staphylococcus epidermidis. Small discs soaked in antibacterial and regular soaps are placed on each bacteria plate. After a day in the incubator, you measure the death zone (the clear ring where bacteria could not grow) around each disc.
Compare the death zones to find out whether the antibacterial ingredient makes any real difference.
Hypothesis
The hypothesis is that there will be no difference between antibacterial hand soaps and non-antibacterial hand soaps on killing bacteria.
Method & Materials
You will isolate and grow three different bacterial cultures, mix them in sterile salt water, swab the agar plates, measure 10 micro liters of soap onto test disks, dispense the soap discs on the surface of the inoculated plate, incubate the plates, and measure the diameter of the death zone of the bacteria.
You will need 3 swabs, 6 pipettes, 3 agar plates, 1 caliper ruler, 3 antibacterial hand soaps, 3 non-antibacterial hand soaps, 9 test tubes, 18 soap discs, 10 milliliters of soap, and 1 incubator.
Results
After the experiment, it was found that there was no difference between the antibacterial and non-antibacterial hand soaps in terms of killing bacteria. The death zone diameter of the bacteria was the same for both types of soap.
Why do this project?
This science project is interesting because it tests a common belief that antibacterial soaps are more effective at killing bacteria than regular soaps.
Also Consider
Variations to consider include testing different types of bacteria and testing different concentrations of soap.
Full project details
Additional information and source material for this project are available below.Share this Science Project:
Related Science Fair Project Ideas
Grow bacteria from four differently washed chopsticks on blood agar and find out how long antibacterial soap really needs to work.
Hard
Add garlic extract to E. coli in a petri dish and track whether the bacteria can grow at all over five days.
Hard
Open three types of baby food, leave them out for different lengths of time, and measure which one grows the most bacteria.
Hard
Share this Science Project:
